Nightingale Coupons & Verified Deals – October 2026

Nice little treat

So I decided to try these out and got the Cookie Monster Ice Cream Sandwich. It was pretty good, tasted like actual cookie dough. Shipping took maybe 5 days to get to my place in Ohio, which was fine. They came in a cool box with dry ice, so no melting mess. Just wish they were a bit cheaper, but hey, it's a gourmet thing, I guess. Overall, a good experience.

Decent value, good flavors

I was looking for something special and found Nightingale. I opted for the Peanut Butter Box Ice Cream Sandwich since it was a good price. It arrived in good condition, still frozen solid. The flavor was rich and satisfying. I felt like I got a good deal for what I paid, especially compared to other gourmet ice creams. It was worth the purchase for a first-timer.

Good ice cream sandwiches

Got the Best Sellers Variety Pack. Arrived frozen. Flavors were good. No issues with order. Would buy again.

Reliable for tasty ice cream

I've ordered from Nightingale a few times now, and they're always consistent. This time I got the Custom Build Your Own Box, picking out some Chocolate Espresso and Banana Pudding sandwiches. Just like before, they showed up perfectly frozen, no melt whatsoever. My first order a while back was just as good. It's why I keep coming back when I need a treat. Good quality and dependable shipping every time.

Solid experience, tasty treats

I ordered the Seasonal Sampler Pack online. The website was easy to navigate and placing the order took about five minutes. Shipping was fast; it took 4 days to reach me in California, and everything was still completely frozen thanks to the dry ice packaging. The Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Sandwich was a highlight, really fresh tasting. Customer support was helpful when I had a question about delivery tracking before it arrived. Overall, a smooth transaction and good quality product.